Grading criteria

The following criteria are relevant for determining grades:

1) Content

• Was the talk technically accurate?
• Did the presenter cover the main points of the paper?

2) Presentation

• Was the talk well organized?
• Were the slides easy to follow and understand?
• Was time appropriately managed?

3) Insights

• Was the presenter able to critically evaluate the material presented?
  
• Did the presenters have additional insights to the topic beyond what was covered in the paper?

4) Questions

• Did the presenter give clear and correct answers to questions?

5) Participation

• Did the student actively participate in discussion of other presentations?